Forums » Off-Topic

Looking for some critizism on an couple of art pieces I did

12»
Dec 13, 2005 Chikira link
Hey guys mind giving me any suggestions on these pieces? Their all work related and any suggestions are welcome.

Paintings







(actually a kind of space horse) unfinshed



Hand-Draw Concepts

(drawing) (Space horse)


Dec 13, 2005 Tyrdium link
Holy @#$%, those are pretty. How'd you make starfield1 and planet1?
Dec 13, 2005 Chikira link
Would take a while to explain, but a few simple techniques I used gave some very good results,

Btw Thanks :)
Dec 14, 2005 Cunjo link
http://deviantart.com <-- good place for critiques... just sign up, upload, and beg for some attention on the overpopulated forums.

I'm there under the same name, though I really don't fish for critiques anymore... I don't have the means to shoot more photos, and my digital art skills aren't worth wasting time on.
Dec 14, 2005 Chikira link
I know what you mean, deviant art is to crowded.
Dec 15, 2005 toshiro link
The Exodus looks like Fett's Slave I. While that is not a bad thing as such, it's the first thing that came to my mind when I looked at it. Other than that, very nice concept.

The sea/space horse is interesting... imagine a band of space nomads, would provide material for very interesting missions/storylines. Also, very nicely drawn.

The planets ad stars... very good artwork. Especially the planet in smoke. An allusion to comets?
Dec 15, 2005 Chikira link
Could the planet be the comet? why yes it may just be. :)
Dec 15, 2005 who? me? link
i like the planet1 and starfield1

the planetinacloud looks kinda funky for some reason i cant quite put my finger on,
Dec 15, 2005 Chikira link
I see the problem. on the right side in the thick of the clouds it looks like your seeing through the planet to the stars, ill have to fix that lol

Thanks
Chikira
Dec 15, 2005 who? me? link
yeah, and also the clouds kinda take away from the 3d look of the planet, dunno if thats a problem or not, maybe make the clouds not as thick
Dec 16, 2005 Chikira link
IT might be that I need to do some rim lighting on the clouds and edge of the planet and finish the background up.
Dec 16, 2005 LeberMac link
Chikira, I know this will seem like a pedantic question, but can you give us an idea of how old you are? It's hard to give constructive artistic criticism without a frame of reference.
Dec 16, 2005 Chikira link
15 Lebermac.
Dec 17, 2005 LeberMac link
Well, see, that changes everything. Being 20 years older than you, I can look at those ship & seahorse drawings and say... "Hey, that's the kind of stuff I used to do when I was 15 and bored to tears in English class!" I hope that means it's good.

What is your technique for the planets? Do you use an actual 3D program, or do you use something else, like the spherize command in Photoshop?

And I can tell you like that Trajan font. (You used it in the samples for the Vendetta website everywhere!) That's OK 'cause it's a kickass font.
Dec 17, 2005 Chikira link
Lol, I made a round selectionon photoshop and built it up from scratch, no shperizing necessary if you know the basics of perspective. Of course I have alot more stuff I could post but that would give away things about the project to soon

I should be posting a realistic shoe done for my art class soon.
Dec 17, 2005 Chikira link
Heres the dumb shoe I was talking about.

Dec 18, 2005 toshiro link
Did you alter the proportions of that shoe sketch? It looks like it is a little too long...
If you do a realistic drawing/painting, you might want to use 'boundary boxes' that roughly contain the object, which you draw at the very beginning and erase later. You won't be needing them after a while anyway, but I found that they help.

Since I'm younger than LeberMac, I might not have as much authority, but I do drawings and design sketches in my spare time as well, most of which won't ever 'go live'. That doesn't mean they're for nought, since whenever I do a design, I invest time and effort to
a) (hopefully) solve a problem and
b) further my drawing skills.
Dec 18, 2005 Chikira link
Lol I did use a box and believe it or not thats what the shoe looks like.
Dec 18, 2005 toshiro link
Hmm... then maybe I got it all wrong. I'm sorry for trying to be smart...
Dec 19, 2005 Chikira link
Lol nah I tought the same thing when I looked at it, the person wearing it must have had big toes or something odd about their foot.