You ninny!

Yeah right; viking thinks the whole world should follow these commandments for every discussion and people shouldn't be allowed to make any statements unless they conform to these rules. How stupid is that!

Less stupid than you!

This can't be true because it doesn't account for daylight savings time.

No True Scotsman would believe this.

Luckily Ecka is anything but a true Scotsman, therefore this list is invalid.

[edit]happy now, TRS?[/edit]

Greenwall, savet and lecter, you've missed the point of the thread - its clearly a forum game - you each need to go back edit your posts and give examples of the commandments.

Skinwalker started us off excellently with ad hominem and then I followed with straw man fallacy, greenwall came in and ruined it with another as hominem and we descended into anarchy from there.

Whistler delivered a good generalisation but its in the wrong order.

Make it right!

Please show me where it says anything about playing a forum game.

Oh, I see. You think that because everyone believes everything "TheRedSpy" has to say, this must be a forum game right?

Ecka puts ice in his scotch :(

No True Scotsman is a logical fallacy not included in the 10. Briefly, it is an attempt to recover after a generalization attempt has been thwarted. The culprit then tries to redefine the term in order to work around the refutation.

"No Scotsman would actually wear a Utilikilt!"

"My uncle Angus wore a Utilikilt to the day he died!"

"No TRUE Scottsman would wear a Utilikilt!"

I have 11 commandments logic

YAH ! I win the forum game 11 is greater then 10

Thanks for playing

Now let's play the 11 commandments of illogical